ICRP Reviewer FAQs

Welcome to the ICRP Peer Review FAQ page! Peer review is a fundamental element of scholarly publishing, ensuring the accuracy, quality, and integrity of academic research. Here, we address common questions about the peer review process to help demystify this crucial activity.

Should you have further inquiries not covered below, please reach out to our Customer Service Team.

About Peer Review

What peer review model does ICRP use?
ICRP adopts the single-anonymous peer review model, where the identities of the reviewers are concealed from the authors, but the authors' identities are known to the reviewers. This approach enables reviewers to impartially assess submissions without influence from the authors.

How can peer reviewing benefit my career?
Peer reviewing offers several career advantages, including:

1. Expanding Knowledge: Engage with the latest research in your field, enhancing your expertise.
2. Networking: Connect with leading researchers and join a community dedicated to advancing scholarly communication.
3. Improving Your Own Work: Gain insights into what constitutes high-quality research, informing your own submissions.

Pre-Review Process

What qualifications are needed to be a peer reviewer?
Reviewers at any career stage can contribute, provided they possess sufficient expertise in the relevant subject area and are committed to conducting thorough reviews.

How do I decide if I should accept a review invitation?
Accept if the manuscript matches your expertise, you have no conflicts of interest, and you can meet the review deadline. Otherwise, it's best to decline.

How do I become a peer reviewer for ICRP?
Interested individuals can apply through our reviewer application form. While completion does not guarantee immediate review opportunities, it makes you a potential candidate for future assignments.

How are reviewers selected?
Reviewers are chosen by Academic Editors based on manuscript relevance and the reviewer's expertise.

What constitutes a conflict of interest, and when should I declare one?
A conflict of interest arises when personal, financial, or professional interests might compromise or appear to compromise a reviewer's impartiality. If potential conflicts exist, they should be declared upon accepting a review assignment.

Peer Review Process

What is the deadline for submitting a peer review?
Reviewers typically have 14 days from accepting the invitation to submit their review.

What should my review cover?
Refer to our Peer Review Checklist for guidance on what to include in your review.

How do I navigate ICRP’s manuscript tracking system?
For assistance with our tracking system, please consult the provided user guide or contact your Editorial Assistant for support.

Post Peer Review

What recognition will I receive for completing a peer review?
ICRP acknowledges reviewers with certificates, and LinkedIn badges, and encourages participation in initiatives like ASAPbio's ‘Publish Your Reviews’ to highlight the value of open peer review dialogue.

How can I claim my reviewer certificate?
Certificates are issued annually. If you require yours sooner, please contact our Customer Service.

What if I want to stop receiving review invitations?
To cease reviewing for ICRP, please inform the Academic Editor or the Editorial Assistant associated with your reviews, or reach out directly to the journal's contact email.

For any further questions, our Customer Service Team is here to help.